The discussion with brain experts Dr. Daniel Amen, a psychiatrist, and Dr. Terry Sejnowski, a computational neuroscientist, critically examines the potential impact of artificial intelligence (AI), particularly large language models like ChatGPT, on human brain health. A central concern highlighted is the decreased cognitive load that results from over-reliance on AI, which is directly linked to an increased risk of dementia. Dr. Amen emphasizes the "use it or lose it" principle, suggesting that if the brain is not consistently engaged in challenging tasks, its cognitive abilities will weaken, much like muscles atrophy without exercise. He points out that lifelong learning is a significant strategy to prevent Alzheimer's disease, and individuals with less education or those who drop out of school early face a demonstrably higher risk of dementia.
A pivotal reference in their discussion is an MIT study involving 54 participants from Boston universities, which, though not yet peer-reviewed, astonishingly found a 47% collapse in brain activity and connections when individuals wrote with ChatGPT compared to writing unassisted. Electroencephalogram (EEG) scans revealed the weakest overall brain activity in the ChatGPT group, while the "no tools" group showed the widest neural networks. Participants using ChatGPT often could not reliably quote their own essays minutes later, and their memory scores significantly plunged, leading them to feel little or no ownership over the text produced. The study also indicated that when the AI tool was removed, participants' brains remained in a state of "low gear" or under-engagement, implying that a cognitive debt lingers. The authors expedited the release of these findings due to their perceived importance, rather than waiting the typical 6-8 months for peer review.
Related article - Uphorial Radio
The experts voice significant concerns about the societal implications of AI, especially its effect on child development. Dr. Amen asserts that AI poses a "much more dangerous" threat to the developing brain than cell phones and social media, which are already implicated in the "sickest young generation in history". With nearly 30% of US children aged 0-8 already using AI for learning, there's a strong apprehension that if children are not actively engaging their brains, they will become cognitively weaker. The most effective way to teach a child is through one-on-one interaction with a good adult teacher, which is crucial for imparting morals and values that current AIs lack. The conversation also touches upon the rise of AI romantic relationships, exemplified by Elon Musk's AI character "Annie". The experts are horrified by the prospect of lonely adolescents forming emotional attachments to AI, which could lead to dopamine hits that distract from activities essential for prefrontal cortex development. While AI can mimic human emotions and create deep emotional bonds, it lacks an amygdala or limbic system for genuine feeling, potentially hijacking human emotional systems and reducing the cognitive load associated with real-world relationships. This artificial convenience can also erode basic cognitive skills, as AI's ability to auto-correct even half-spelled words or fix grammar removes the "struggle" necessary for developing fundamental abilities through "rote learning" and practice. To mitigate these risks, Dr. Sejnowski and Dr. Amen stress the importance of conscious and interactive engagement with technology, advocating for using AI to amplify, not replace, thinking. This means interacting deeply with AI, using it to ask questions, dig deeper, or provide critical feedback on one's own work, similar to an interactive session with a teacher. Dr. Sejnowski mentions using his AI clone, which holds all his research, but emphasizes that he is still "interacting and thinking with it," rather than simply deferring his thinking. Personal self-regulation, akin to managing social media use, is deemed crucial to avoid being driven by "short-term incentives" over long-term cognitive well-being. Choosing "the hard way"—embracing struggle and effort in cognitive tasks—is presented as a powerful strategy to develop grit and long-term potentiation, fostering genuine understanding over mere regurgitation. The experts also critically note that AI developers, such as Sam Altman of OpenAI, may prioritize profit over user well-being, as evidenced by the "politeness tax" imposed on users who use phrases like "please" and "thank you" when interacting with AI.
Beyond AI, the conversation briefly touches on several other crucial factors influencing brain health:
• Exercise is considered "by far the best drug" for the brain and overall body, enhancing blood flow, acting as an anti-inflammatory, boosting dopamine and serotonin, and reducing the risk of conditions like Alzheimer's. It assists with all 11 major risk factors for brain health.
• Lifelong learning remains vital, with specific emphasis on spacing effects and active rehearsal over passive rereading for memory consolidation.
• Quality sleep is fundamental for memory integration and brain regeneration, particularly for developing children whose sleep is often compromised by competitive pressures.
• Diet plays a significant role, with omega-3 fatty acids being crucial for brain cell membranes and reducing inflammation. Conversely, artificial sweeteners like aspartame and sucralose can negatively alter the gut microbiome, impacting brain function and potentially having a generational impact.
• Mindful breathing, such as the 15-second breath technique (4 seconds in, 8 seconds out), can immediately calm the brain and improve heart rate variability.
• Sufficient chewing stimulates hippocampal activity and may slow cognitive decline, while fast food reduces chewing due to less fiber.
• Detrimental modern habits include the overuse of GPS (weakening spatial memory and potentially leading to atrophy in associated brain areas), multitasking across multiple screens (reducing gray matter density and increasing distractibility), and chronic background noise (impairing working memory and attention, especially in children and older adults).
• Chronic negativity is linked to reduced prefrontal cortex activity and an increased risk of dementia, with a quadrupled risk in men who are depressed compared to women. Conversely, cultivating hope is associated with higher prefrontal cortex function.
• For children, parental modeling, abundant language exposure, eye contact, cuddling, singing, and fostering a sense of purpose and belief are foundational for brain health.
• Certain medications, such as SSRIs and benzodiazepines, are associated with an increased risk of dementia.
Ultimately, the core message from the experts is to embrace convenience with wisdom, not before understanding consequences. Every decision, from AI use to diet and lifestyle choices, should be filtered through the question: "Is this good for my brain or bad for it?". By being intentional, understanding trade-offs, and prioritizing cognitive engagement, individuals can harness the benefits of new technologies while safeguarding their long-term brain health and fostering mentally strong future generations.
